Thursday, October 07, 2010

Why "It Gets Better" is the wrong message to send--and why we should do it anyway

When the "It Gets Better" project began a couple weeks ago, I didn't feel like I had anything actively helpful to contribute. As I said at the time, my not inconsiderable bullying had nothing to do with being queer--except maybe in the older form of the word. But, as we've now reached the "backlash" portion of the news cycle, I do feel as though I have things to say. Things, which I hope are helpful.

We have reached a point where not only has there been backlash over Dan Savage being the head of the movement (nb: that backlash happened immediately, I don't want to make it seem as though I've missed that), but where shitbags are posting things called "It Gets Worse." In these delightful musings, bigoted assholes co-opt the momentum of "It Gets Better" to further bully and hate-vomit on the QUILTBAG community.

But, sadly, that brings me to my next point.

"It Gets Better" is a terrible message, because it doesn't. It changes, sure. But as the blog 49percent asks, what, gets better, exactly? (The link referred to there is also well-worth reading.)

The answer, in short, is that as you get older, you are better able to choose your family and surround yourself with people who love, respect, and support you. So yes, in that sense, it's a wonderful message.

But it does precious little to help now.

"It gets better" is something I told myself for oh, about seventeen years. Or, from the age of five through the age of about 22. I said it to myself for differing reasons, and because of different hardships. I leaned on those words so often that by the time I was 27, and went through the worst fucking year of my life, they had lost all meaning.

They had become so devoid of power, that they became nothing more than pandering to my ears. In my destroyed state of mind, hearing them drove me to nearly ruining two of the closest and most important relationships of my adult life.

So we need to be careful what we're telling these kids. Because if, as an adult, without suicidal tendencies, those words drove me to extremes, I don't want to know how these kids will react.

"It gets better" is a placeholder. What these kids need are the tools and support to make it better now.

One of the other things that I find especially problematic about Dan Savage's "It Gets Better" project, is that The Trevor Project was already here. It was already here, and it was already inclusive to PoC and the whole QUILTBAG. While it's good to have more than one organization for an issue, Dan Savage is such a divisive figure, that it's diluting the message, not strengthening it.

And, The Trevor Project is all about giving kids the tools and support to make it better now.

So while I think it's wonderful and important to see celebrities filming videos telling us that they know where troubled youth have been, how many news cycles until It Gets Better peters out and these kids are left, once again, alone?

Let's make it better now.

7 comments:

Anonymous said...

Aw, this was an exceptionally good post. Spending some time and actual effort to produce a really good article… but what can I say… I procrastinate
a lot and don't manage to get nearly anything done.

Also visit my web-site how to buy a car with bad credit
my web page > buying a car with bad credit,buy a car with bad credit,how to buy a car with bad credit,buying a car,buy a car,how to buy a car

uầy ôi said...

Nice blog !!!
thanks for sharing
Thiet ke nha dep tai quan 12 |
Nha xinh tại quan 6 |
Biet thu dep tai quan 1 |
Thiet ke biet thu dep tai |
Mau nha pho tai quan 9 |
Nha pho dep tai quan go vap |

24 hour check cashing said...

United Check Cashing offering you the best services with 100% satisfaction within very short period.

www.usacheckcashingstore.com/san-diego said...

Attempt to get a payday advance via telephone. While applying on the web may appear to be simple, it is normally better to call for more data. Not exclusively would you be able to ask any inquiries you have, you can likewise ensure you see every one of the terms and states of the credit.

24 hour check cashing Holiday said...

Are you looking to cash into a checking account, the total amount usually cannot be immediately accessed; there may be a waiting period for the check to clear?

Cash Advance said...

Figure your every day and month to month consumptions, and attempt to evade superfluous buys. You ought to likewise fabricate some sparing, so that there will be no compelling reason to acquire cash for surprising costs or crises.

Pradeep Singh said...

Very Good Point about the your blog when I search in google your blog get ranking good all blog post are very informative. Kindly post about Interior Designs In Chennai & Modular Kitchen in Chennai related.